Two of Venice's finest, pulling in opposite directions. Book Aman Venice for 24 suites inside a frescoed Grand Canal palazzo, central and intimate. Book Belmond Hotel Cipriani for a garden resort on Giudecca with the city's only Olympic-size pool.
Affiliate disclosure: when you book through links on this page we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. We never accept payment for placement or rankings.
Same city, two opposite ideas of luxury.
Aman Venice is a hotel of 24 suites inside Palazzo Papadopoli, a sixteenth-century palace on the Grand Canal in San Polo. It opened in 2013, keeps the original frescoes and gilded salons, and adds the calm, pared-back Aman hand on top. It is private, central and small, and it is where you stay to be in Venice, on foot, with the Rialto minutes away.
Belmond Hotel Cipriani is the opposite by design. It sits on the tip of Giudecca island, across the water from St Mark's, with gardens, a spa, tennis and a large heated outdoor pool, almost unheard of in Venice. With around 95 rooms it is a resort, reached by a short complimentary launch, and it trades the city's bustle for space and quiet.
One puts you in the heart of Venice; the other gives you room to breathe beside it. The case for each follows, with the honest trade-offs.
| Aman Venice | Belmond Hotel Cipriani | |
|---|---|---|
| Size | Intimate; 24 suites in one palazzo | Larger; around 95 rooms and suites, resort-scale |
| Setting | Grand Canal, San Polo; central and walkable | Giudecca island; reached by shuttle launch |
| Pool | None; two rare private gardens and a spa | Large heated outdoor pool, gardens, tennis |
| Style | Frescoed palazzo, calm contemporary Aman layer | Classic garden resort, lagoon views |
| Season | Open year-round | Seasonal; closes over winter |
| Best for | Intimacy, frescoes, a central base on foot | Space, a pool, gardens, a relaxed week |
What you get: The most private and design-led luxury stay in Venice, 24 suites inside a frescoed sixteenth-century palace on the Grand Canal, central enough to explore on foot.
The Aman's edge is intimacy and place. Palazzo Papadopoli keeps its painted ceilings and gilded salons, and Aman lays its quiet, uncluttered style over the top rather than competing with the building. Two private gardens, almost unknown in central Venice, and a calm spa make it feel like a borrowed palace rather than a hotel. The San Polo position puts the Rialto within an easy walk and St Mark's a short stroll or boat ride away, so the whole city is on your doorstep. It is small enough that staff learn your name within a day.
Honest trade-off: There is no pool, the contemporary-Aman restraint can read as austere to anyone wanting full Venetian opulence, and with only 24 suites it books out far ahead at the top of the market's rates. Who this isn't for: travellers who want a pool, gardens and resort facilities, or a relaxed week with room to spread out, are better served by the Cipriani.
Weighted: Service 25%, Rooms 20%, Romance / Value / Food 15% each, Location 10%. Scores are HotelsForKings editorial judgments of the hotel's luxury offer, not guest review averages.
What you get: A rare thing in Venice, a true garden resort with a large heated pool, on the quiet tip of Giudecca, a five-minute private launch from St Mark's.
The Cipriani's advantage is space and the pool. Founded in 1958 by Giuseppe Cipriani of Harry's Bar, it spreads across gardens, lawns and lagoon-facing buildings on Giudecca, with around 95 rooms and suites, a spa, tennis and the large heated outdoor pool that no central Venice hotel can match. The complimentary shuttle launch crosses to St Mark's in minutes, so you get the sights when you want them and calm when you don't. It is the better choice for a longer, slower stay, and the easier one with children, where a pool and room to roam earn their keep.
Honest trade-off: Being on Giudecca means you depend on the launch rather than stepping straight into the city on foot, and the hotel closes over the Venetian winter. Its larger scale makes it less intimate than the Aman. Who this isn't for: travellers who want to walk out of the lobby into the heart of Venice, or who value a hotel small enough to feel like a private house, will prefer the Aman.
Weighted: Service 25%, Rooms 20%, Romance / Value / Food 15% each, Location 10%. Scores are HotelsForKings editorial judgments of the hotel's luxury offer, not guest review averages.
At this level the difference between a great Venice stay and a frustrating one is detail: which Aman suite actually faces the Grand Canal, when the Cipriani opens and closes for the season, and which shoulder weeks keep the light without the crowds. We track both and send the honest version, one email at a time.
Book Aman Venice when you want to be inside Venice: a short, intense stay in a frescoed palazzo on the Grand Canal, 24 suites, the Rialto minutes away on foot, and the most private service in the city. It is the choice for couples and for anyone who came for the city itself rather than a resort beside it.
Book Belmond Hotel Cipriani when you want space, a pool and gardens, and a slower week, with the sights a short launch away when you want them. It is the easier stay with children and the better one for unwinding. The Aman wins on intimacy and position; the Cipriani wins on space, the pool and calm, just confirm its season first.
It depends on the kind of Venice stay you want. Aman Venice is a 24-suite hotel inside a frescoed sixteenth-century palazzo directly on the Grand Canal, the most private, central and design-led luxury address in the city. Belmond Hotel Cipriani is a larger garden resort on Giudecca island, with the only Olympic-size pool in Venice and a short private-launch shuttle to St Mark's. Choose the Aman for intimacy, frescoes and a walkable position; choose the Cipriani for space, a pool, gardens and a resort rhythm rare in Venice.
Only the Cipriani. Belmond Hotel Cipriani has a large heated outdoor pool, long described as Olympic-size, set in its gardens on Giudecca, which is almost unheard of in central Venice and a major part of its appeal in summer. Aman Venice has no pool at all; as a palazzo on the Grand Canal it offers two rare private gardens and a spa instead. If a pool matters to your trip, the Cipriani is the clear choice of the two.
Aman Venice is more central. It sits on the Grand Canal in the San Polo district, within an easy walk of the Rialto Bridge and a short walk or short boat ride from St Mark's, so you can step out into the heart of the city on foot. The Cipriani is on Giudecca island, across the water from St Mark's, and you reach the main sights by the hotel's complimentary shuttle launch, a five-minute crossing. That separation buys the Cipriani its calm and its gardens, but the Aman is the easier base for exploring on foot.
They sit at opposite ends of the scale. Aman Venice has just 24 suites within Palazzo Papadopoli, which makes it one of the most intimate luxury hotels in the city and means it books out far ahead. Belmond Hotel Cipriani is far larger, with around 95 rooms and suites spread across the main building, gardens and annexes on Giudecca. The Aman feels like a private palazzo; the Cipriani feels like a resort, with the wider range of rooms, restaurants and facilities that scale allows.
No. Belmond Hotel Cipriani is seasonal and closes over the Venetian winter, typically operating from spring to late autumn and shutting around the end of October before reopening in spring. Aman Venice operates year-round. If you are planning a winter or early-spring trip, confirm the Cipriani's season before booking; for a winter Venice stay, the Aman is the more reliable of the two to be open.
Both are superb honeymoon hotels, and the choice mirrors the wider split. Aman Venice is the more intimate and romantic in a quiet, exclusive way: 24 suites, frescoed salons, and a Grand Canal setting made famous as a celebrity wedding venue. The Cipriani is romantic in a more expansive, resort way, with gardens, the pool, lagoon views and space to unwind across a longer stay. For a short, intense, in-the-thick-of-Venice honeymoon choose the Aman; for a relaxed week with a pool and gardens choose the Cipriani.
Subscriber only hotel offers, suite upgrade alerts, and one honest review every Sunday. Free, weekly, unsubscribe anytime.