Book Cheval Blanc when one of its six maisons stands where you are going: the craft, the three-star kitchens and the Dior and Guerlain spas out-deliver Aman address for address. Book Aman for the other fourteen countries, and for a silence Cheval Blanc does not sell. Neither earns its rate everywhere; here is where each one does.
Affiliate disclosure: when you book through links on this page we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. We never accept payment for placement or rankings.
Start with what neither brand will say in its own brochure. Cheval Blanc, the hotel arm LVMH launched at Courchevel in 2006, is a luxury brand with almost nowhere to stay: six addresses on Earth, two of them closed for half the year with the seasons. Aman, founded by Adrian Zecha at Amanpuri in Phuket in 1988 with rates reportedly five times the local competition, is a serenity brand that now also sells branded residences, a members' club, a second hotel marque and a Fifth Avenue tower. Both charge close to the ceiling of every market they enter. Neither publishes a loyalty programme. The only question that matters is what the money buys.
At Cheval Blanc, it buys density of craft. Three of the six maisons hold three-Michelin-star restaurants, all confirmed again in the 2026 Michelin Guide France: Plenitude in Paris, which won its three within a year of opening; Le 1947 at Courchevel, five tables under Yannick Alleno, three stars since 2017; and La Vague d'Or in St-Tropez. The spas are run with Dior in Paris and Guerlain in the Seychelles. The Paris maison itself is 72 rooms by Peter Marino inside Henri Sauvage's 1928 Samaritaine building. This is vertical integration as hospitality, and at its best nothing else in the luxury hotel trade matches the finish.
At Aman, the money buys absence: of crowds, of noise, of most other guests. Thirty-six hotels in twenty countries pursue one idea with unusual discipline, enormous space per guest and service that appears and disappears on cue. The audit question for Aman is different. The hard product is often plainer than the rate implies, the kitchens have never been the argument, and under chairman and chief executive Vlad Doronin the monastic pitch now coexists with an expansion business. The full case for each follows.
| Cheval Blanc | Aman | |
|---|---|---|
| Best for | Craft, food and spas in six specific places | Privacy and quiet, almost anywhere |
| Founded | 2006, Courchevel, by LVMH | 1988, Amanpuri, Phuket, by Adrian Zecha |
| Portfolio | 6 maisons; Porto Cervo announced | 36 hotels in 20 countries, plus Janu |
| Ownership | LVMH | Aman Group; Vlad Doronin, chairman and CEO |
| Three-star dining | Plenitude, Le 1947, La Vague d'Or (2026 guide) | None; food is not the brand's case |
| City flagship | Paris: 72 rooms, Peter Marino, the Samaritaine | New York: 83 suites, Crown Building, 2022 |
| Newest opening | Seychelles, December 2024, 52 villas | Aman Nai Lert Bangkok, 2025, 52 suites |
| Loyalty programme | None | None |
| Rate tier | $$$$ | $$$$ |
The con first: Cheval Blanc is barely a brand at all by hotel-industry arithmetic. Six addresses, and the map is unforgiving: if your year does not pass through Paris, the French Alps, the Riviera, St-Barth, the Maldives or Mahe, LVMH has nothing to sell you. Courchevel is a winter house and St-Tropez a summer one, so at any given moment part of the portfolio is dark. Scarcity also means the rooms sell out the way couture does, and entry pricing sits at the palace tier of every market it occupies.
Now the delivery, which is the point. The brand began in 2006 at Courchevel, added Randheli in the Maldives in 2013 and the former Isle de France on St-Barth in 2014, took St-Tropez, and then in September 2021 produced its thesis statement: Cheval Blanc Paris, 72 rooms by Peter Marino inside the 1928 Samaritaine building on the Seine, with a 30-metre pool in a Dior spa below ground. The sixth maison opened on Anse Intendance beach on Mahe in December 2024, 52 villas by Jean-Michel Gathy with a spa built with Guerlain. A seventh is announced for Porto Cervo in Sardinia. The pattern is consistent: one trophy site per destination, finished to a standard that reads less like hotelkeeping than like product design.
The kitchens are where the audit ends quickly. Plenitude won three Michelin stars in 2022, inside a year of opening. Le 1947 at Courchevel, five tables under Yannick Alleno, has held three since 2017. La Vague d'Or at St-Tropez holds three under Arnaud Donckele, who also cooks Plenitude in Paris. All three hold their stars in the 2026 Michelin Guide France. For a six-hotel brand to keep three of the world's three-star dining rooms is a ratio no hotel company of any size approaches, and it is the cleanest evidence that the rate buys measurable substance here.
The ruling on the promise: the maison conceit, a house rather than a hotel, mostly survives contact with the guest. What the brochure underplays is that the houses are also shop windows: the spa is Dior, the partners are LVMH, and the brand assumes your appetite for that ecosystem. If you want luxury without a logo within reach, this is not your church.
Weighted: Service 25%, Design 20%, Romance / Value / Food 15% each, Location 10%. Scores are HotelsForKings editorial judgments, not guest review averages.
The con first: Aman's rate is the steepest promise in hospitality, and the hard product does not always cash it. The rooms are superb but deliberately plain; the restaurants are competent rather than destinations, and no Aman table holds three Michelin stars; the bill arrives priced as if both were otherwise. When Aman New York opened reservations in 2022, One Mile at a Time filed the story under ridiculous pricing, which is the genre of headline the brand now generates on schedule. And the serenity pitch has acquired company: under Vlad Doronin, Aman also sells branded residences, a private members' club and Janu, a second, busier brand that opened in Tokyo in 2024. A monastery with a development pipeline is still quiet, but you are entitled to notice the cranes.
What the rate does buy is the most disciplined idea in luxury hotels, held since Adrian Zecha opened Amanpuri in 1988 at rates reportedly five times the neighbours. Aman builds few rooms on big land, staffs them invisibly and lets silence do the marketing. Thirty-six hotels in twenty countries now run the same play, which is precisely what Cheval Blanc cannot offer: an Aman exists near most places worth flying to, from Venice to Kyoto to the Utah desert. The consistency is real; the brand's repeat guests, the self-described Aman junkies, are the most loyal customer base in the industry despite there being no points programme to chain them.
Even the New York gamble has largely held. Eighty-three suites in the Crown Building on Fifth Avenue, opened in August 2022, all of them enormous by Manhattan standards, with a jazz club below and a spa across three floors; the Michelin Guide has since handed the hotel its top hotel distinction of three Keys. The newest city house, Aman Nai Lert Bangkok, opened in 2025 with 52 suites above a private park, the brand's first urban hotel in Thailand. Aman in cities sells the same product as Aman on islands: insulation, purchased by the night.
The ruling on the promise: Aman delivers the absence it advertises, and charges as if absence were caviar. If your definition of luxury is space, quiet and not being performed at, the rate is defensible and nothing else does it as well at scale. If you expect the kitchen, the spa brand or the room itself to justify the invoice line by line, Aman will lose that audit to Cheval Blanc every time the two share a map.
Weighted: Service 25%, Design 20%, Romance / Value / Food 15% each, Location 10%. Scores are HotelsForKings editorial judgments, not guest review averages.
Where the maps overlap, book Cheval Blanc. In Paris against Aman's city hotels, in the Maldives against Aman's islands, the LVMH house wins on what can be measured: three-star kitchens, Dior and Guerlain spas, rooms finished like product. It is the rare luxury brand that over-delivers against its own advertising.
Everywhere else, which is most of the world, book Aman, and book it for the right reason. You are not paying for the plate or the marble; you are paying for distance from other people, supplied with a consistency no one else manages across 36 hotels. In one line: Cheval Blanc earns its rate in six places; Aman earns most of its rate in thirty-six.
Where both brands operate, Cheval Blanc delivers more per night: three of its six maisons hold three-Michelin-star restaurants, and the Dior and Guerlain spas are products Aman cannot match. But Cheval Blanc exists in only six places. Aman wins on reach and on its core product, which is space and silence, sustained across 36 hotels in 20 countries.
Cheval Blanc has six maisons: Courchevel, where the brand began in 2006, Randheli in the Maldives, St-Barth, St-Tropez, Paris, and the Seychelles, which opened on Mahe in December 2024 with 52 villas. A seventh is announced for Porto Cervo, Sardinia. Aman operates 36 hotels in 20 countries, plus Janu, its more sociable second brand, which opened first in Tokyo in 2024.
Cheval Blanc, and it is not close. Plenitude in Paris won three Michelin stars in 2022 within a year of opening, Le 1947 in Courchevel has held three stars under Yannick Alleno since 2017, and La Vague d'Or in St-Tropez holds three; all three keep their stars in the 2026 Michelin Guide France. Arnaud Donckele cooks both the Paris and St-Tropez flagships. No Aman dining room competes at that level; the brand has never made the kitchen the argument.
Both open at or near the top of every market they enter, and neither publishes a loyalty programme or award chart to soften it. Aman set the template at Amanpuri in 1988 with rates reportedly five times the local competition, and when Aman New York opened reservations in 2022 the points press filed the news under ridiculous pricing. Cheval Blanc Paris sits at the palace tier of its city. Budget similar money; what differs is what the money buys.
No. Neither brand operates a points programme, publishes an award chart, or offers a status ladder. There is nothing to game and no redemption sweet spot to find; the rate is the rate. Travellers who want luxury with points strategy should look at brands covered in our loyalty guides instead.
Choose by temperament. Cheval Blanc Randheli in the Maldives is the more polished object: LVMH finish, serious food, a one-island stage set. Amanpuri in Phuket and Aman's island resorts sell something plainer and quieter, with more space and fewer performances. Couples who want to be looked after choose Randheli; couples who want to be left alone choose Aman.
Subscriber only hotel offers, suite upgrade alerts, and one honest review every Sunday. Free, weekly, unsubscribe anytime.