Book EDITION for Ian Schrager's design-led lifestyle hotels: spare, luxe rooms, a sceney lobby bar and real nightlife in the city center, with Marriott Bonvoy points behind it. Book Nobu for a restaurant-first brand built around the Nobu kitchen, warmer and more service-led, where the Japanese-Peruvian dining room is the heart of the hotel.
Affiliate disclosure: when you book through links on this page we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. We never accept payment for placement or rankings.
Two guests walk into these hotels expecting different evenings, and the front desk knows it. At an EDITION, the lobby is already half a nightclub, a glamorous bar, music, a crowd that did not necessarily check in, and the welcome is pitched to that energy. At a Nobu, the smell of the kitchen reaches the door, the restaurant is the room everyone is heading for, and the service has the warmth of a chef's house. Same luxury tier, opposite centers of gravity.
EDITION is the design-led brand Ian Schrager introduced with Marriott in 2008, drawing on the nightlife instincts that made him a co-founder of Studio 54. The first hotels opened earlier this decade, The London EDITION in 2013 set the tone, and the brand now runs around 20 hotels worldwide. Because it lives inside Marriott, EDITION stays earn and redeem Marriott Bonvoy points, a real advantage for loyalty travelers.
Nobu Hotels comes at luxury from the kitchen. Built by chef Nobu Matsuhisa with Robert De Niro and Meir Teper, the same trio behind the global Nobu and Matsuhisa restaurants, the brand puts a Nobu dining room at the heart of every hotel and runs roughly 20 properties, from city hotels to resorts like Nobu Hotel Ibiza Bay. It is independent, so there is no big points program, but the food and service are the point. The honest split: book EDITION for design and scene, Nobu for the restaurant and a warmer stay. The full case for each is below.
| EDITION Hotels | Nobu Hotels | |
|---|---|---|
| Best for | Design, lobby scene and nightlife | A restaurant-first, service-led stay |
| Created by | Ian Schrager with Marriott, 2008 | Nobu Matsuhisa, Robert De Niro, Meir Teper |
| Owner / group | Marriott (Bonvoy points apply) | Nobu Hospitality (independent) |
| Signature | Sceney lobby bars, spare luxe rooms | A Nobu restaurant in every hotel |
| Atmosphere | Lively, urban, design-forward | Warm, food-led, often calmer |
| Footprint | ~20 hotels worldwide, growing | ~20 hotels worldwide, growing |
| Loyalty | Marriott Bonvoy | No large chain program |
Signature: A design-led hotel where the public spaces do the talking, a glamorous lobby, a destination bar, a nightclub or terrace, wrapped around calm, pared-back luxe rooms.
EDITION is Ian Schrager's idea of a luxury hotel as a social stage, executed with Marriott's resources. The rooms are deliberately restrained, white oak, soft lighting, little clutter, so the energy lives downstairs, where the bar and lobby are designed to pull in a crowd. The London EDITION, which opened in 2013, became a celebrity fixture and set the template; later hotels in New York's Times Square, Miami Beach, Madrid, Shanghai, Reykjavik and beyond repeat the formula in local registers. The Bonvoy tie-in means a design hotel that still earns points and honors elite status, which is rare in this corner of the market.
It is the choice for travelers who treat the hotel as part of the night out, design lovers, couples and groups who want a great bar downstairs and a sleek room to retreat to, and Marriott loyalists who want their lifestyle stay to count toward status.
Honest trade-off: The scene is the catch. EDITION lobbies and bars can be genuinely loud and busy, and at the flagship hotels the nightlife crowd is a feature, not a bug, which is the opposite of a quiet retreat. The minimalist rooms read as cool to some guests and stark to others, the brand is concentrated in big cities rather than resorts, and service, while polished, is pitched to a younger, faster register than a classic grand hotel.
Weighted: Service 25%, Design 20%, Romance / Value / Food 15% each, Location 10%. Scores are HotelsForKings editorial judgments, not guest review averages.
The 2013 flagship that set the brand's lobby-scene template.
Schrager design dropped into the middle of Manhattan.
Beachfront design hotel with a nightlife pedigree.
Compare head to head in the same Miami Beach market.
Signature: A hotel organized around a Nobu or Matsuhisa restaurant, so the cooking, the omakase, the black cod, the Japanese-Peruvian menu, sets the tone for the whole stay.
Nobu grew the rare way: restaurant first, hotel second. Chef Nobu Matsuhisa, with Robert De Niro and Meir Teper, turned a celebrated restaurant group into a hotel brand, and the kitchen is still the gravity. Rooms carry a quiet Japanese-influenced calm, the service is personal and chef-led, and the dining room usually feeds room service too, so the food is never far. The footprint mixes city hotels with genuine resorts, Nobu Hotel Ibiza Bay is a beachfront property rather than a nightclub with rooms, which gives the brand a softer, more restful side than EDITION.
It is the choice for travelers who book a hotel for the table: food lovers, couples who want a calmer luxury stay, and anyone who would rather the highlight of the evening be dinner than a DJ. The trade-off for that warmth is the lack of a big loyalty engine.
Honest trade-off: Independence costs you points. Nobu has no large chain loyalty program, so frequent travelers cannot bank stays toward status the way they can at EDITION, and recognition depends on the individual hotel. The brand's identity is also tightly bound to one cuisine, which is a joy if you love it and a limitation over a long stay if you do not, and the design, while elegant, is less boundary-pushing than Schrager's. Coverage is still thin in many cities.
Weighted: Service 25%, Design 20%, Romance / Value / Food 15% each, Location 10%. Scores are HotelsForKings editorial judgments, not guest review averages.
If you are choosing Nobu mainly for the food, ask whether the full restaurant menu is available through in-room dining, at most Nobu hotels it is, which means a quiet omakase-style dinner in your room on a jet-lagged night. At EDITION, do the reverse and book the lobby bar or restaurant in advance: at the flagships those spaces fill with non-guests, and walking down from your room does not guarantee a table.
EDITION runs Marriott Bonvoy promotions and suite-upgrade windows, while Nobu's best value moves by property and season. Before you book, we will send the upgrade alerts, the points sweet spots at EDITION, and which Nobu is worth crossing a city for, one honest email at a time.
Book EDITION when the hotel is part of the night. If you want Ian Schrager design, a destination lobby bar and city-center energy, and you value Marriott Bonvoy points and status on a lifestyle stay, EDITION is the sharper, more sociable choice, and the only one of the two that earns toward a major program.
Book Nobu when dinner is the plan. If you want a hotel organized around a great restaurant, warmer service and an easier shot at calm, especially at its resorts, Nobu is the more restful, food-first option. In short: EDITION for the scene, Nobu for the table.
A ranked shortlist, a special offer worth booking, and the overpriced stay to skip. Straight from the editors.
No. Both are design-conscious lifestyle brands, but they lead with different things. EDITION is a design-led hotel brand created by Ian Schrager with Marriott, where the lobby, bar and nightlife are the draw. Nobu is a restaurant-first brand from chef Nobu Matsuhisa, Robert De Niro and Meir Teper, where the hotel is built around a Nobu dining room.
EDITION was introduced in 2008 by Ian Schrager and Marriott, and it sits inside Marriott's luxury group, so it earns and redeems Marriott Bonvoy points. Nobu Hotels is run by Nobu Hospitality, the independent company behind the Nobu and Matsuhisa restaurants, founded by Nobu Matsuhisa, Robert De Niro and Meir Teper. Nobu has no large chain loyalty program.
Nobu, by design. Every Nobu hotel is anchored by a Nobu or Matsuhisa restaurant serving the brand's Japanese-Peruvian cuisine, and that kitchen usually supplies room service too. EDITION has strong, often celebrated restaurants and bars, but dining is one part of a wider design-and-nightlife concept rather than the foundation of the hotel.
Nobu more often. EDITION's lobby bars and nightlife are a core feature, which makes its city hotels lively and sometimes loud, especially at flagships like The London EDITION. Nobu leans warmer and more service-led, and several Nobu properties are resorts such as Nobu Hotel Ibiza Bay, so it is easier to find calm. Always check the specific property.
The two are similar in size. EDITION operates around 20 hotels worldwide and is growing, with recent openings including The Lake Como EDITION. Nobu Hotels runs roughly 20 hotels globally, with many more in development, including new resorts and a long-awaited New York hotel. Both are still expanding rather than mature, so coverage in any one city can be thin.
At EDITION, yes. Because it is a Marriott brand, EDITION stays earn and redeem Marriott Bonvoy points and recognize Bonvoy elite status. Nobu is independent, so there is no comparable chain points program; recognition and perks come from the individual hotel and from booking through a trusted travel advisor program.