Thirty miles of Atlantic separate them, but the real distance is architectural. Nantucket is one preserved grey-shingle town governed by a single discipline; Martha's Vineyard is three towns and three architectures held loosely together. Read the buildings and you have already half-decided which island is yours.
Affiliate disclosure: when you book through links on this page we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. We never accept payment for placement or rankings.
People treat these two as interchangeable summer islands off Cape Cod, the preppy shorthand for old American money on holiday. Architecturally they could hardly be less alike. Nantucket is the more singular object: the entire island was designated a National Historic Landmark in 1966, and a strict commission has held its centre to one weathered-shingle, white-trimmed vocabulary ever since. Walk from the cobblestoned Main Street past the Federal and Greek Revival mansions the whaling captains built, and the town behaves like one continuous, restored composition. There is almost no false note, because almost no false note is permitted.
Martha's Vineyard refuses that kind of unity, and that is its character. It is the larger island, with three distinct towns that speak three architectural languages. Edgartown is the white, sober, Greek Revival captains' village, the closest the Vineyard comes to Nantucket's restraint. Two towns north, Oak Bluffs holds Wesleyan Grove, a thirty-four-acre camp-meeting settlement of roughly three hundred Carpenter Gothic cottages dripping jigsaw-cut “gingerbread,” a National Historic Landmark in its own right, ringed around an open-air Tabernacle. Vineyard Haven is the working harbor. No single code governs them.
That contrast decides the hotels and most of what follows. Nantucket's luxury sits inside the protected fabric, restored captains' houses and a harborside grande dame held to the island look. The Vineyard's stock is more varied because the island is, ranging from an 1891 shingle-style resort to an antiques-laden Relais & Châteaux inn to family addresses on the sand. Neither island is the “better” one. One is a masterclass in coherence; the other in range.
| Nantucket | Martha's Vineyard | |
|---|---|---|
| Best for | Architectural discipline and one preserved town | Architectural range and three distinct towns |
| The fabric | National Historic Landmark island (1966); uniform grey shingle, white trim | Edgartown classicism plus Oak Bluffs gingerbread; no single code |
| Design hotel | Greydon House, 1850s captain's house by Roman & Williams | The Charlotte Inn, antiques-filled Relais & Châteaux |
| Grande dame | The White Elephant, harborside, recently renovated | Harbor View Hotel, opened 1891, landmark veranda |
| Getting there | Thirty miles out; longer ferry or short flight | Closer in; frequent ferries from Woods Hole |
| Getting around | Compact and protected; walk, cycle, leave the car | Larger road network; a car is genuinely useful |
| The feel | Adult, design-minded, single-key coherence | Family-friendly, plural, three towns wide |
The case: Nantucket is what happens when a whole island is treated as a single building worth saving. The National Historic Landmark designation and the design commission that enforces it mean the town centre has kept its weathered cedar shingle, its white trim and its cobblestones with a consistency you will not find on the mainland, the Federal and Greek Revival houses of the whaling fortune still reading as one ensemble. Into that fabric the hotels fit rather than fight. Greydon House is the sharpest example: an 1850s Greek Revival sea captain's house joined to a mansard-roofed wing, its interiors designed by New York's Roman & Williams around the conceit of a whaling captain's collected rooms, grooved panelling nodding to ship's cabins, antiques gathered as if from far voyages. It is the most considered small hotel on either island.
The grandes dames hold the line too. The White Elephant is the harborside classic, reopened after a renovation that left its green-shuttered, shingled character intact, while The Wauwinet takes the island idea to its edge, a Relais & Châteaux country inn out on the haulover where the harbor and the open Atlantic nearly meet. For a traveller who reads streets and rooflines, Nantucket gives the rare pleasure of a place that means it.
Honest trade-off: Discipline has a cost, and on Nantucket the cost is sameness and money. The grey-shingle code that makes the town coherent also makes it monotone; visitors who want colour, surprise or contrast can find the perfection a little airless. It is the harder island to reach, thirty miles out by a longer ferry or a small plane, and that remoteness is priced into peak-summer rates that run steep even by island standards. Families needing space and variety, and anyone who finds rigorous preservation closer to a theme than a town, will be happier across the sound.
Weighted: Service 25%, Design 20%, Romance / Value / Food 15% each, Location 10%. Scores judge each island's luxury hotel stock and built fabric, not its beaches, and are HotelsForKings editorial judgments, not guest review averages.
The case: The Vineyard's strength is exactly what Nantucket suppresses: contrast. Edgartown gives you the sober side, white Greek Revival captains' houses lining streets that could almost pass for Nantucket, and the island's grandest hotel sits among them. The Harbor View Hotel opened in 1891 as a shingle-style resort and still presents its signature wrap-around veranda to Edgartown harbor, the long line of oversized chairs and the lighthouse beyond it one of New England's set-piece hotel views, now behind a multimillion-dollar restoration. A few minutes away, The Charlotte Inn plays the opposite register, an antiques-filled, English-mannered Relais & Châteaux property that has been a member since 1992.
Then the island does something Nantucket never could. Two towns up in Oak Bluffs stands Wesleyan Grove, the 19th-century Methodist camp-meeting settlement whose roughly three hundred Carpenter Gothic cottages, all pointed arches, scalloped bargeboards and Technicolor paint, cluster around an open-air Tabernacle in a National Historic Landmark district. Within a single short drive the Vineyard swings from grave white classicism to the most exuberant domestic architecture in New England. Families get the practical dividend too, in beaches, in the Oak Bluffs carousel, and in water's-edge resorts like the Winnetu Oceanside near South Beach.
Honest trade-off: Range comes at the price of coherence, and the Vineyard can feel less curated than its neighbour. The drive between Edgartown, Oak Bluffs and Vineyard Haven means more car and more summer traffic, the towns vary in polish, and at the very top the island lacks a single design hotel as tightly conceived as Greydon House. If you want one immaculate town you can walk end to end, the Vineyard's sprawl and its three competing characters will read as dilution rather than richness.
Weighted: Service 25%, Design 20%, Romance / Value / Food 15% each, Location 10%. Scores judge each island's luxury hotel stock and built fabric, not its beaches, and are HotelsForKings editorial judgments, not guest review averages.
Choose by what you want the place to be, not by which name sounds grander. Both islands are superb; the only real mistake is booking the one whose temperament fights your week.
| Trip | The ruling | Why |
|---|---|---|
| One immaculate town to walk | Nantucket | A National Historic Landmark island held to one design code; the centre reads as a single composition. |
| Architectural variety in a day | Martha's Vineyard | Edgartown classicism to Oak Bluffs gingerbread within a short drive; three towns, three vocabularies. |
| The best-designed small hotel | Nantucket | Greydon House, an 1850s captain's house reworked by Roman & Williams, outdesigns anything across the sound. |
| A grand veranda and a harbor view | Martha's Vineyard | The Harbor View Hotel, opened 1891, keeps its landmark wrap-around veranda over Edgartown harbor. |
| Travelling with children | Martha's Vineyard | More beaches, the Oak Bluffs carousel and water's-edge resorts like the Winnetu built for families. |
| Leaving the car behind | Nantucket | The protected centre is compact enough to walk or cycle; a car is more burden than help. |
Rule for Nantucket if architecture is what moves you and coherence is the prize. One island, one design code, one continuous grey-shingle town that has been guarded as a National Historic Landmark since 1966, with hotels like Greydon House and the White Elephant fitted carefully inside it. Accept the remoteness, the high-summer rates and a certain studied sameness as the price of near-perfect preservation.
Rule for Martha's Vineyard if you would rather have range than uniformity. Three towns and three architectures, from Edgartown's white captains' houses to the Carpenter Gothic gingerbread of Oak Bluffs, a grand 1891 veranda at the Harbor View and more room for families to spread out. Trade the single-key perfection of its neighbour for an island that contradicts itself on purpose, and is more interesting for it.
The shortlist worth booking, the deal worth catching, and the overpriced one to skip. From the editors, no noise.
It depends on what you want the buildings to do. Nantucket is the more disciplined choice: the whole island is a National Historic Landmark district held to one of the strictest design codes in the country, so the grey-shingled whaling town reads as a single coherent work, with hotels like the Roman & Williams-designed Greydon House and the harborside White Elephant inside it. Martha's Vineyard is larger and architecturally plural, offering Edgartown's white Greek Revival captains' houses, the Carpenter Gothic gingerbread cottages of Oak Bluffs, and the 1891 Harbor View Hotel. Choose Nantucket for coherence, the Vineyard for variety.
They are interesting in opposite ways. Nantucket is interesting for its restraint: weathered cedar shingle, white trim, cobblestone Main Street and Federal and Greek Revival whaling mansions, all preserved with near-total consistency since the town's designation as a National Historic Landmark in 1966. Martha's Vineyard is interesting for its contrasts, holding the sober classicism of Edgartown and, two towns away in Oak Bluffs, the polychrome jigsaw-scrollwork cottages of Wesleyan Grove, a National Historic Landmark of roughly 300 Carpenter Gothic houses around an open-air Tabernacle. One island is a single key; the other is a chord.
The standouts are Greydon House, the White Elephant and The Wauwinet. Greydon House pairs an 1850s Greek Revival sea captain's house with a mansard-roofed wing, its interiors designed by New York's Roman & Williams around the fiction of a whaling captain's collected rooms. The White Elephant is the harborside grande dame, reopened after renovation. The Wauwinet is a Relais & Châteaux country inn out on the haulover between the harbor and the open Atlantic. All three are within the protected historic fabric.
The leading addresses are the Harbor View Hotel and The Charlotte Inn, both in Edgartown. The Harbor View opened in 1891 as a grand shingle-style resort and keeps its landmark wrap-around veranda over the harbor after a multimillion-dollar renovation. The Charlotte Inn is a Relais & Châteaux property, antiques-filled and English in sensibility, a member since 1992. For families on the water, the Winnetu Oceanside near South Beach is the practical pick.
Martha's Vineyard is the easier island. It sits closer to the mainland with more frequent ferries from Woods Hole and a larger road network linking Edgartown, Oak Bluffs and Vineyard Haven, so a car is genuinely useful. Nantucket is thirty miles out to sea, a longer ferry or a short flight, and its centre is so compact and protected that walking, cycling or a hotel transfer usually beats driving. The Vineyard rewards a road trip; Nantucket rewards leaving the car behind.
Martha's Vineyard leans family: three towns, more beaches, the Flying Horses carousel in Oak Bluffs and resorts like the Winnetu built around children. Nantucket skews adult and design-minded, its compact town and intimate inns suiting couples and architecture lovers more than large family groups. Neither rule is absolute, but if you are travelling with young children the Vineyard's range is the safer bet, while a couple chasing one beautifully made town will prefer Nantucket.