Massachusetts · 12 Hotels Listed · The Faraway Island
Nantucket
Thirty miles out to sea and a century back in time. Gray cottages, white roses, and the kind of summer light New England keeps to itself.
Thirty miles out to sea and a century back in time. Gray cottages, white roses, and the kind of summer light New England keeps to itself.
Ranked by overall occasion score. Every hotel verified, priced, and visited in 2025–2026.
"The harbor lawn at sunset is Nantucket itself. A century-old flagship that earned its name and never apologised for it."
"A Relais & Châteaux peninsula with the harbor on one side, the Atlantic on the other. Topper's restaurant alone is reason to come."
"The 1891 grande dame on Easton Street, restored without irony. Two pools, a children's program, and the rare Nantucket address that welcomes a stroller."
"Twenty rooms behind a Broad Street facade. Roman & Williams interiors that prove design hotels can still feel like Nantucket — and improve it."
"The most stylish thing to happen to a Nantucket lobby in fifty years. Younger crowd, surf prints, and a pool deck the island didn't know it needed."
"Reborn after the 2022 fire, three tiers of porch above Old Town. The harbor view from the top deck remains one of the great cocktail hours in New England."
"You sleep on the wharf itself. Private cottages with kitchens, the Steamship Authority a hundred yards off, and the harbor at the foot of the bed."
"A short walk to Jetties Beach and the easiest pool on the island. Less storied than the harbor-front grandes, but the value is unembarrassed."
"Easy Street, easy stay. A young, well-edited boutique that gets the brief: walk to the ferry, walk to dinner, walk to bed."
Nantucket is the rare honeymoon destination that gets quieter the closer you stand to the ocean. Thirty miles offshore, with no chain hotel allowed and an entire island designated a National Historic Landmark, the place exists precisely to slow two people down. Our verdict: White Elephant for the iconic harbor flagship every couple eventually books, The Wauwinet for the most romantic dining room on the eastern seaboard, and Greydon House for couples who'd rather hide than parade.
An anniversary on Nantucket is a return more than a discovery. The same gray shingles, the same Sankaty light, the same dinner at the inn that asked your name once and remembered it for a decade. White Elephant for the milestone everyone takes a photo of. The Wauwinet for couples who learned long ago that great service is quiet. 76 Main for the smaller, more private register.
The flagship that has kept score on Nantucket anniversaries for a century.
Our ranked list, with the one-sentence verdict on each.
The harbor-front flagship that has defined Nantucket luxury for over a century — the lawn, the lounge, the unimpeachable address.
Auberge-affiliated 1850 inn on a private peninsula — Topper's restaurant is the most romantic dining room in New England.
The 1891 grande dame restored as the island's most family-capable resort — two pools, a kids' program, and a front porch that explains the place.
The boutique that proved a Nantucket inn can also be a design hotel — Roman & Williams interiors inside an 1850s house.
Marine Home Center's stylish reset of the old Mariner — a younger, design-forward Nantucket with a real pool deck.
Three tiers of porch above Old Town — the harbor view from the top deck is one of New England's great sunset perches.
Sleeping on the wharf itself — private cottages with kitchens, the harbor at the foot of the bed.
A short walk to Jetties, the easiest pool on the island, and the rare Nantucket address that lets families breathe.
Easy Street boutique that gets the brief — walk to the ferry, walk to dinner, walk to bed.
An 1883 sea captain's house on Main Street, eighteen rooms deep — the most quietly correct inn on the cobblestones.
Nantucket runs on a short, punishing season. June through early September is the peak — long days, beaches at full tilt, the Fourth of July parade down Main Street, the Boston Pops on Jetties Beach in August. Late April brings the Daffodil Festival, the spiritual opening of the island: a million blooms, a vintage car parade out to Sconset, and the year's first proper rosé. October is the great shoulder month — the Cranberry Festival, the Pumpkin Festival on Main Street, beach walks without crowds, and rates fifteen to twenty-five percent below August. The first weekend of December delivers Christmas Stroll, the most charming ninety-six hours on the island calendar — gray shingles dressed in greenery, Santa arriving by Coast Guard boat, and rooms booked six to nine months ahead. Mid-December through March, much of the island closes; a handful of inns and the Nantucket Hotel & Resort stay open for those who actually want to be alone.
Town is the obvious choice for first-time visitors — cobblestone streets, the harbor, the ferries, and walking distance to nearly every restaurant worth the reservation. White Elephant, The Cottages and Lofts at the Boat Basin, The Veranda House, Faraway, The Breeze, and 76 Main all sit in or beside it. Old Town, the dense historic core, is where the captain's houses and the whaling-era wealth live; Greydon House anchors Broad Street here. Sconset, seven miles east, is the clifftop residential village — Sankaty Head Lighthouse, climbing roses on tiny shingled cottages, and a pace that makes Town look frantic. Madaket, on the western end, is the sunset address: the Atlantic at the back door, very few hotels, and the best red light on the island. Surfside, on the south shore, is the family beach — broad sand, lifeguards, and easier reach by bike path. Cisco, further west on the south shore, is the surf and brewery zone — Cisco Brewers, surfing lessons, and a less polished register.
Nantucket is the most expensive island in the Northeast, and the rates reflect it. White Elephant runs $700 to $2,500-plus per night in peak summer, depending on room type and view; harbor-view suites at the height of August comfortably exceed $3,000. The Wauwinet operates in a similar tier. Mid-range boutique hotels — Greydon House, Faraway, The Veranda House, 76 Main — sit in the $500 to $900 range in season. Family-scale resorts like the Nantucket Hotel & Resort and The Beachside at Nantucket run $500 to $1,200 depending on room and date. Shoulder season (late May, early June, late September, October) is reliably twenty to thirty percent below peak. Christmas Stroll weekend prices match or exceed August. Almost every hotel imposes a minimum-stay requirement of two to four nights in season, and most charge a sizeable resort or service fee on top of the room rate.
Book in December for July and August — the better rooms at White Elephant and The Wauwinet are gone by February. Christmas Stroll weekend (the first weekend of December) needs to be reserved six to nine months out. Getting to the island matters as much as the hotel: the Steamship Authority high-speed ferry from Hyannis takes an hour and is the standard route, but vehicle reservations sell out months ahead and most visitors are better off leaving the car on the mainland. Hy-Line Cruises runs a parallel passenger service. To fly, Cape Air operates frequent short hops from Boston and Hyannis, and JetBlue runs seasonal direct service from JFK and a handful of other east-coast cities to Nantucket Memorial Airport (ACK). Most luxury hotels will arrange airport or ferry pickup; ask at the time of booking. An ACK plate on the back of an old Wagoneer is the local social currency, but you don't need a car for an in-Town stay — the island is twelve miles end to end and bikes and ride-shares cover the rest.
American norms apply, gently inflated for the island. A bellhop or porter: $3 to $5 per bag. Housekeeping: $5 to $10 per night, left daily. Concierge for a Topper's reservation, a Cisco surf lesson, or an off-island fishing charter: $20 to $50 depending on the difficulty. Valet: $5 each time the car is brought up. In hotel restaurants, fifteen to twenty percent is standard if service is not already added; many island restaurants now include an automatic eighteen to twenty percent service charge in season, which makes verifying the check before tipping again a sensible habit.
Other destinations worth your consideration.
Tell us your occasion and we'll narrow it down. Honeymoon, anniversary, family week, or quiet October escape — Nantucket has the right address for each.
Choose Your OccasionNew hotel openings, deal alerts, and occasion-specific guides — weekly.
