Book The Plaza when you want New York to feel like a fairy tale: a castle on Central Park, tea under a stained-glass dome, the grandest arrival in the city. Book The St. Regis when you would rather be quietly, completely looked after, a butler in your room and a martini at the King Cole Bar. Four blocks apart, two different ideas of romance.
Affiliate disclosure: when you book through links on this page we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. We never accept payment for placement or rankings.
Stand at Grand Army Plaza at dusk and you can see the whole argument. To your right, the Pulitzer Fountain and the green edge of Central Park; above it, the white château front of The Plaza, lit like a stage. Walk four blocks south on Fifth Avenue and the second contestant barely announces itself: The St. Regis keeps its grandeur indoors, behind a quieter Beaux-Arts facade at 55th Street. Both opened within three years of each other in the early 1900s, both have hosted a century of famous nights, and both are still, unmistakably, grand New York hotels. The choice between them is really a choice between two kinds of romance.
One is the romance of spectacle. The Plaza is the hotel everyone pictures when they picture old New York: the carriage horses, the Palm Court, the marble and gilt, the address that films and books have made shorthand for arrival. Stay here and the city performs for you, and you, a little, perform back. The other is the romance of being cared for. The St. Regis sends a butler with the room, every room, and trades some of the wattage for a hush that lets a couple disappear into their own evening. Neither is better. They answer different wishes.
What they share is that the building is the experience. Neither is a beach or a view you sit and stare at; the pleasure is interior, the rooms, the bar, the ritual of a great old house doing what it has always done. So the honest way to choose is to ask which ritual you want: tea beneath the stained glass at The Plaza, or a Red Snapper under the Old King Cole mural at The St. Regis. The full case for each follows.
| The Plaza | The St. Regis New York | |
|---|---|---|
| Best for | The Central Park fairy tale and the grand arrival | Quiet intimacy and a butler in every room |
| Opened | 1907, French Renaissance by Hardenbergh | 1904, Beaux-Arts, built by John Jacob Astor IV |
| Location | Fifth Avenue at Central Park South | Fifth Avenue at 55th Street, four blocks south |
| Size | 282 rooms, including 102 suites | 171 rooms, including 67 suites |
| Managed by | Fairmont | Marriott (St. Regis) |
| Signature space | The Palm Court, stained-glass dome, afternoon tea | King Cole Bar, Maxfield Parrish mural, the Red Snapper |
| Signature service | Grand-hotel polish; concierge-led | St. Regis Butler Service in every room |
| The view | Central Park from park-facing rooms | Fifth Avenue and midtown; no park frontage |
| Feels like | A landmark that performs | A private house that attends to you |
The con first: The Plaza is famous, and fame has a footfall. The lobby and the Palm Court draw a steady current of non-residents who have come to see the place, take tea, photograph the dome, and on a busy afternoon the ground floor feels more like a landmark than a private retreat. A couple looking for hush will find it upstairs, not down. The hotel is also a working icon rather than a discreet hideaway; you trade some privacy for the privilege of staying inside the postcard. And in a building this large and this storied, the rooms vary, the courtyard-facing ones do not give you the reason you came.
That reason is the park, and at the right hour it answers completely. Ask for a park-facing room and wake to Central Park filling the window, the carriage horses assembling below, the light moving across the green; it is the most romantic morning view in the city for a couple who wants New York itself as the scenery. Downstairs, the Palm Court serves its celebrated afternoon tea beneath a restored stained-glass ceiling, now with live music through a Jazz at Lincoln Center collaboration, a daytime ritual made for an anniversary. Step out the door and you are at Grand Army Plaza, the Pulitzer Fountain, the entrance to the park, and a short walk to Bergdorf Goodman and Fifth Avenue.
The Plaza gives a couple the version of New York they already have in their heads, and then lets them live inside it for a night or two. The arrival under the awning, the gilded corridors, the sense of a hundred famous evenings before yours, this is theatre, and for the right occasion theatre is exactly the gift. It is the more iconic stay, and the one that will make the photographs.
Who should book it: couples who want the grand, recognizable New York, the park at the door, tea under the dome, the storybook arrival, and who will happily share the lobby with the legend in exchange for staying inside it. Splurge on a park-facing room; the view is the whole point.
Weighted: Romance 25%, Location 20%, Rooms / Dining / Service 15% each, Heritage 10%. Scores are HotelsForKings editorial judgments, not guest review averages.
The con first: The St. Regis does not have the park, and it does not have the postcard. There is no front-row Central Park view from the room, no carriage horses at the door, none of the instant recognition that makes The Plaza a destination in itself; the address is quieter and the romance is more interior. It is also the smaller, more formal house, where the pleasure is in restraint rather than spectacle, and a couple chasing buzz or a scene will find it almost too composed. And the King Cole Bar, rightly famous, is popular; the room is intimate and fills early in the evening.
What you get in return is the most cosseting stay of the two, and for many couples that is the more romantic thing. Every room and suite comes with St. Regis Butler Service, a personal butler who unpacks, presses, draws the evening, and performs the signature wake-up with coffee or tea; the effect is of staying in a great private house where someone has quietly anticipated you. The suites are generous and classically beautiful, made for an evening that never has to leave the room. Downstairs, the King Cole Bar pours the Red Snapper, the hotel's own original Bloody Mary, beneath Maxfield Parrish's 1906 Old King Cole mural, one of the great cocktail rooms anywhere, and the place to begin or end a night.
The St. Regis is the choice for a couple who measures luxury by how little they have to ask for. It keeps the Gilded-Age grandeur but turns the volume down, so the night belongs to the two of you rather than to the lobby. Four blocks from The Plaza, it offers the opposite pleasure: not to be seen arriving, but to be perfectly, privately attended to once you have.
Who should book it: couples who want intimacy over icon, a butler-run evening, a martini under the mural and a quiet, beautiful room to return to, and who will trade the park view for being completely looked after. Ask your butler to set the room for your occasion before you arrive.
Weighted: Romance 25%, Location 20%, Rooms / Dining / Service 15% each, Heritage 10%. Scores are HotelsForKings editorial judgments, not guest review averages.
If you want the New York of the imagination, the castle on the park, tea under the stained glass, the arrival you have pictured for years, book The Plaza, and book a park-facing room. Nothing in the city delivers the grand storybook night so completely, and for a honeymoon or a first big trip together that spectacle is the whole gift.
If you would rather be quietly, completely cared for, a butler in your room, a martini under the Old King Cole mural, a beautiful suite to disappear into, book The St. Regis. It trades the park view for the most cosseting stay of the two. In one line: The Plaza is the more romantic icon; The St. Regis is the more romantic stay.
We send subscribers the room to request, the suite worth the splurge, and one honest review every Sunday. Free, weekly, unsubscribe anytime.
It depends on the kind of romance you want. The Plaza is the grander gesture: a French Renaissance castle on Central Park, afternoon tea under the stained-glass dome of the Palm Court, the most photographed arrival in New York. The St. Regis is the more intimate stay, with a personal butler attached to every room and the hush of a smaller Beaux-Arts house off Fifth Avenue. Choose The Plaza for the spectacle and the park; choose The St. Regis for being quietly, completely looked after.
The Plaza, opened in 1907, is a 282-room French Renaissance landmark at Fifth Avenue and Central Park South, Fairmont-managed, famous for the Palm Court and its movie-icon status. The St. Regis, opened in 1904 by John Jacob Astor IV, is a smaller, more discreet 171-room Beaux-Arts hotel four blocks south at 55th and Fifth, Marriott-run, defined by St. Regis Butler Service in every room and the King Cole Bar. The Plaza is the bigger icon; The St. Regis is the more personal.
Yes. St. Regis Butler Service is included for every room and suite, not only the top tiers. The butler handles unpacking and packing, pressing, the signature wake-up ritual with coffee or tea, and last-minute requests around the clock. It is the single thing that most separates a stay at The St. Regis from a stay at The Plaza, where service is excellent but not delivered through a dedicated personal butler in the same way.
The Plaza, decisively. It sits directly at the southeast corner of Central Park at Grand Army Plaza, so the park, the Pulitzer Fountain and the horse carriages are at the door. The St. Regis is about four blocks south at 55th Street and Fifth Avenue, a short walk from the park but without the front-row view. For couples who want the park itself as the backdrop, The Plaza wins on location.
Ideally both, since they are four blocks apart. The Plaza's Palm Court serves its celebrated afternoon tea beneath a restored stained-glass dome, with live jazz through a Jazz at Lincoln Center collaboration. The St. Regis's King Cole Bar is the home of the Red Snapper, the hotel's original Bloody Mary, served under Maxfield Parrish's 1906 Old King Cole mural. Tea at The Plaza is the daytime ritual; a King Cole martini is the evening one.
Both are strong choices, and the right one follows your taste. For a honeymoon built around a sense of occasion, Central Park walks and a grand room, The Plaza delivers the storybook version of New York. For an anniversary where the pleasure is in being attended to, dinner kept simple and a butler-drawn evening, The St. Regis is the more cosseting. Either way, request a high floor and ask in advance about celebration touches.
Subscriber only hotel offers, suite upgrade alerts, and one honest review every Sunday. Free, weekly, unsubscribe anytime.