A 1922 waterfront resort on Sturgeon Bay's quiet shore, with a private sand beach, indoor and outdoor heated pools, complimentary kayaks and bicycles, tennis and basketball, and water-view suites with full kitchens and double whirlpool tubs.
"A century-old summer resort that quietly became a year-round suite hotel, with a private beach, two heated pools, and a paddle programme that makes it the most kid-friendly upscale option on the south end of the peninsula."
Bay Shore Inn opened in 1922 as a seasonal summer resort on the wooded shoreline of Sturgeon Bay, two and a half miles north of the downtown bridge district on Bay Shore Drive. The property was rebuilt and converted to year-round condominium-style suite buildings in 1991, and it has run since then as a hybrid suite hotel and small private community, with a small consistent operating team and unusually loyal repeat guests. The setting is the property's anchor: a private sand beach runs along the bay frontage for roughly 240 metres, with a public-feeling but in fact reserved waterfront that is the cleanest small-resort beach on this side of the peninsula.
There are one and two-bedroom water-view suites and a small number of three-bedroom cottages set behind the main lodge. Every suite includes a king bed in the master, a double whirlpool tub, a fully equipped kitchen with full-size appliances rather than a kitchenette, a separate living and dining area, and a private balcony or patio onto the bay or the gardens. Suites in the upper categories add wood-burning stoves and bay-facing sliding glass walls. The interior treatment is more residential than hotel, which is consistent with the property's condo history, and the suites are large enough that a multi-night booking lands closer to a small vacation rental than a hotel stay.
The shared facilities are the property's other point of pride. Indoor and outdoor heated pools run year-round and summer respectively, framed by a small fitness room. A small fleet of paddle boats, row boats, kayaks, and stand-up paddle boards sits on the beach for guest use without charge, with bicycles for the shoreline path. A clay tennis court and a basketball court sit at the rear of the property under the trees, and the shorefront has multiple grill stations and picnic areas for in-suite dining. There is no on-site restaurant, but downtown Sturgeon Bay's restaurant row is six minutes away by car and the suite kitchens are properly stocked for self-catering nights.
Operating signature here is the family rhythm. Bay Shore Inn is the Door County property where multi-generational families settle into a one-week pattern of beach mornings, paddle afternoons, in-suite dinners, and pool evenings. The staff know the regulars, the front desk runs in a quieter cadence than the larger village resorts, and the operating quirks (no lobby bar, no full restaurant, lean front-of-house) are part of what makes the property feel less like a hotel and more like a small private association.
For a one-week family Door County booking Bay Shore Inn is the strongest single choice on the south end of the peninsula. The private beach, two heated pools, and complimentary paddle and kayak fleet remove most of the day-trip logistics, the suite kitchens reduce the dining-out load to two or three nights, and the three-bedroom cottage works for a multi-generational booking without compromise.
An anniversary at Bay Shore Inn skews quieter and more reflective than the village-centre alternatives. Book a one-bedroom bay-view suite midweek in shoulder season, take the kayaks out at golden hour, and grill on the beach for at least one evening. The operating quiet here is the point.
Bay Shore Inn works as a low-intervention wellness booking. The beach, the two pools, the kayaks, the tennis court, and the lake-path bicycles structure a simple daily pattern; pair morning yoga with daily paddle and a single dinner reservation downtown, and the week composes itself.
4205 Bay Shore Drive
Sturgeon Bay, WI 54235
United States
Two and a half miles north of downtown Sturgeon Bay
One and two-bedroom water-view suites
Three-bedroom shoreline cottages
From $158/night one-bedroom
From $245/night two-bedroom
Cottages from $390/night
Check-in: 4:00 PM
Check-out: 10:00 AM
Established 1922; year-round operation since 1991
Private sand beach (240 metres of shoreline)
Indoor and outdoor heated pools
Complimentary kayaks, paddle boats, bicycles
Tennis and basketball courts
Suite kitchens with full appliances
Double whirlpool tubs and king beds
Complimentary WiFi throughout
From $158/night. Two-bedroom suites and the cottages book three to four months ahead for July and August one-week stays.
See Current Rates →The peninsula's largest resort on the Egg Harbor bluff, with indoor and outdoor pools and suite product.
Lake Michigan beachfront suites with golden sand and shallow swim water on the lake side of the peninsula.
A 161-room downtown Sturgeon Bay resort on the waterfront next to the Steel Bridge, with indoor and outdoor pools.
Off peak pricing, suite upgrades, and subscriber only offers, flagged only when the value is real.