Highlander Mountain House

The building came first

Read the address before the brochure: this is an 1885 clapboard farmhouse on Main Street, reportedly built for a retired sea captain from Charleston, South Carolina. The bones are the point. The renovation kept the original wide-plank wood flooring and the exposed timber framing rather than papering over them, so the structure still reads as a 19th-century mountain house rather than a gut-rebuilt shell wearing a heritage label. For decades it operated as The Main Street Inn; the current property is the same frame under a far more deliberate hand.

That hand belongs to hotelier Jason Reeves, who reopened the inn in 2020 after a roughly eight-month renovation. Reeves came to it from commercial real estate, interior design, and a track record restoring period houses in Charleston — a useful provenance for a building that needed conservation as much as decoration. The result is 18 rooms split between two registers: the Main House, finished in an English-country idiom, and a more rustic, Appalachian-leaning Bunkhouse. Same property, two distinct material palettes, and the price ladder follows the contrast.

The design, decoded

The stated brief is “an English eclectic country house transposed into Appalachia,” and for once the marketing line is accurate to what the eye finds. The interiors layer bespoke furniture, antiques, custom lighting, patterned wallpaper, and deliberately odd objects — Victorian-era taxidermy among them — into rooms that feel collected rather than specified. The design narrative reaches for regional sources too: the Cherokee, the Scots-Irish homesteaders, the moonshiners, and the avant-garde circle around nearby Black Mountain College. It is maximalist, and it is coherent, which is the harder of the two to pull off.

What this is not is a resort. There is no spa, no pool, no event floor — a useful corrective to anyone arriving expecting a five-star programme. The Highlander competes on atmosphere and craft inside a small footprint, and on a Main Street position that puts the shops and restaurants of downtown Highlands within a short walk. Judge it as a design-led inn and it holds up; judge it against an amenity-heavy mountain resort and you will be counting things that were never meant to be there.

The Ruffed Grouse, downstairs

The on-site tavern, The Ruffed Grouse, is the social heart of the place and a genuine reason to book here rather than nearby. It is built around a custom white-oak bar, marble-topped pub tables, overstuffed couches, and a large wood-burning stone fireplace, with a Main Street–facing patio for warm weather. Chef Chris Durm cooks regionally-influenced fare across breakfast, lunch, and dinner, sourcing from Blue Ridge farmers; the bar pours La Colombe coffee, rotating craft beer, and an edited list of biodynamic and organic wines from small producers.

One scheduling caveat that changes the calculus: the tavern closes roughly December through April. In those months the inn's strongest single feature goes dark, and a stay leans entirely on the room and the town. Plan a cold-season visit knowing the fireside dining you came for may not be open.

Who it suits — and who it doesn't

It suits couples and design-minded travelers who want a walkable Main Street base, a strong tavern, and interiors with a point of view — an anniversary or a long-weekend in town more than a week-long resort holiday. The honest cons are worth stating plainly. At 18 rooms it sells out on peak fall-foliage and event weekends, so book well ahead. There is no spa, pool, or fitness facility, so amenity-driven guests should look elsewhere in the area. The Bunkhouse rooms are intentionally more rustic than the Main House — charming to some, basic to others — so match the category to your expectations. And the Main Street setting trades seclusion for convenience: this is town-center, not a forest hideaway.

Practical information

Frequently asked

Also worth a look in Highlands