Quick answer: Casa Cipriani fills the 1909 Battery Maritime Building at Manhattan's southern tip with 47 harbor-facing suites, Thierry Despont interiors, and a members-only club upstairs. Book it for water views, balconies, and distance from Midtown crowds. Skip it if anyone in your party sleeps lightly: ferry horns and helicopters are part of the address.
HotelsForKings scores are editorial judgments against our published criteria, informed by a synthesis of recent verified guest reviews and documented facilities. How we score.
For a century the Battery Maritime Building loaded Brooklyn ferries at the foot of Whitehall Street. Casa Cipriani opened inside it in August 2021, after Marvel Architects restored the 1909 Beaux Arts terminal and added a steel and glass crown, with interiors by the late Thierry Despont. The conversion produced something Manhattan almost never builds: a 47-suite hotel where the public rooms face open water.
The Cipriani family runs the building as a private members club with a hotel inside it. The floors hold an event hall, a wellness center and spa, the suites, and a top level club with a jazz cafe, bars, and a restaurant behind the glass addition. An overnight booking includes club access for the length of the stay, which is the practical reason to pay the rate: you get the membership experience without the membership.
A harbor-facing one, full stop. All 47 keys are suites, and the water side is the entire point: a private balcony with the Statue of Liberty, Governors Island, and the Brooklyn Bridge arranged in front of you, plus closets large enough to earn repeated mentions in guest reviews. The side nearest the Downtown Manhattan Heliport at Pier 6 trades that panorama for rotor noise that starts early; if the harbor categories are sold out, consider different dates rather than a different side.
Two noise sources here are structural, not incidental. Staten Island Ferry horns carry across the slip at all hours, and recent reviewers describe being woken in the small hours; the heliport sits one pier east. Sensitive sleepers should request a high floor on the water side and pack earplugs anyway.
The address is 10 South Street, the absolute southern tip of Manhattan. South Ferry (1 train) and Whitehall Street (R and W) are under five minutes on foot, and the Governors Island ferry leaves from the same building in season. Midtown is 25 to 35 minutes door to door by subway. That is the honest trade: you are buying the harbor, not proximity to the Met, the park, or Broadway. For a Midtown-centric trip, The Mark or Aman New York make more sense.
Patterns across recent Tripadvisor and Booking.com reviews are consistent. Praise concentrates on the suites themselves: the size, the closets, the balconies, and the club floor's food and evening jazz. The recurring complaints are just as specific: ferry and helicopter noise on the wrong side of the building, a front desk several guests describe as cool toward non-members, and card holds or billing errors at check-in that took effort to unwind. None are dealbreakers; all are worth knowing at this price.
A warmer welcome at the door for hotel guests, posted clarity on card holds at check-in, and heavier soundproofing on the heliport side. The hardware is world class; the software occasionally forgets that suite guests paid more than most members.
Casa Cipriani is the most distinctive opening downtown Manhattan has seen in a decade and the only New York hotel where every morning starts with open water. We score it 8.8 overall: Rooms 9.1, Service 8.5, Location 8.7. Book it for a romantic weekend built around the harbor and the club; see our full New York ranking if your trip lives uptown.
Affiliate disclosure: when you book through links on this page we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. We never accept payment for placement or rankings.
Yes. An overnight reservation includes access to the club spaces, including the jazz cafe, bars, and wellness center, for the duration of the stay. Without a room or a membership you cannot get past the lobby.
The harbor-facing suites with private balconies. They frame the Statue of Liberty, Governors Island, and the Brooklyn Bridge from the room. Avoid the side closest to the Downtown Manhattan Heliport if noise bothers you.
It depends on your room. Recent guest reviews repeatedly mention Staten Island Ferry horns at night and morning helicopter traffic from the heliport one pier east. Request a high, harbor-side suite and the noise largely disappears behind the glass.
About 25 to 35 minutes by subway. South Ferry (1 train) and Whitehall Street (R and W) stations are under a five minute walk from the front door, so the connection is easy, just not short.
August 2021. Marvel Architects restored the 1909 Battery Maritime Building and added its steel and glass crown; the interiors are by the late Thierry Despont.
If your trip is built around downtown, the harbor, and the club floor, yes; nothing else in New York offers this setting. If you plan to spend every day above 42nd Street, the commute erodes the value and an Upper East Side address serves you better.
Subscriber only hotel offers, suite upgrade alerts, and one honest review every Sunday. Free, weekly, unsubscribe anytime.